Document deletes by ID on sharded collection

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
1 message Options
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view

Document deletes by ID on sharded collection

Brian Panulla
I have a Near-Realtime Search implementation on Solr Cloud 7.5 and I'm
having an issue with deleting documents from a sharded collection.

I'm deleting documents right now using a query for the document ID, and
everything seems to be working properly, aside from the fact that deletes
are *really slow*. Delete request come in via a message queue, and
overnight when most of our document removals happen the queue backs up,
sometimes taking several hours to clear a few thousand documents.

  "delete": {
    "query": "+id:12345678"

We've seen suggestions that document deletes by ID are preferred due to
performance, so I built an implementation that works correctly with a
single unsharded core on a standalone Solr server. But when I try deletes
by ID on our sharded development SolrCloud cluster the deletes are
unreliable. It's not clear to me how they happen, if at all. I've had some
luck sending the delete directly to the node where the document lives, but
even that doesn't seem to work consistently. The cluster is sharded using
the compositeId router on a second field common to all of our records if
that matters.

  "delete": {
    "id": "12345678"

Does anyone have any advice about what *should* work? Is there some
contributing factor I'm missing, like how we're sharding? We're trying to
move away from full DataImporHandler reindexes in the future as a means of
removing deleted documents, but we need to be able to delete specific
documents directly in an efficient way before this could be a reality.